[{"data":1,"prerenderedAt":361},["ShallowReactive",2],{"locale-alternates:\u002Fai-visibility-is-also-a-state-concern":3,"post-\u002Fai-visibility-is-also-a-state-concern":8},{"path":4,"alternates":5},"\u002Fai-visibility-is-also-a-state-concern",{"en":4,"tr":6,"de":7},"\u002Ftr\u002Fai-gorunurlugu-devletlerin-de-gundeminde","\u002Fde\u002Fki-sichtbarkeit-ist-auch-ein-staatliches-thema",{"page":9,"translations":205,"nav":211,"related":339,"random":348},{"id":10,"title":11,"body":12,"categories":176,"category":179,"changeHistory":179,"date":180,"description":181,"disclosures":182,"draft":185,"extension":186,"firstLiveAt":179,"image":187,"imageAlt":188,"kind":189,"lang":190,"meta":191,"navigation":192,"omitGermanLocalizationDisclosure":185,"path":4,"publishedAt":179,"readingTime":193,"rights":179,"seo":194,"seoTitle":195,"slug":196,"sources":179,"stem":196,"tags":197,"translationKey":202,"type":203,"updated":179,"__hash__":204},"posts\u002Fai-visibility-is-also-a-state-concern.md","AI Visibility Is Also on States’ Agendas",{"type":13,"value":14,"toc":168},"minimark",[15,29,32,37,46,55,69,78,82,91,99,108,111,118,122,125,128,131,134,140,144,152,165],[16,17,18,19,28],"p",{},"According to ",[20,21,27],"a",{"href":22,"rel":23,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.theguardian.com\u002Fworld\u002F2026\u002Faug\u002F26\u002Ffake-thinktank-israel-ai-propaganda",[24,25],"nofollow","noopener","_blank","the Guardian's reporting",", the Hanover Institute published 124 reports, totalling more than 560,000 words, between 6 and 14 August 2026.",[16,30,31],{},"The interesting business question is larger than the volume of content produced in a week. The communication logic that leads brands to care about how they are described in AI answers is reaching state communication too. Reporting around the Hanover Institute gives us a concrete case to examine that shift. But it helps to separate the public record, the reporting's interpretation, and what remains unknown.",[33,34,36],"h2",{"id":35},"a-publishing-site-presented-as-a-think-tank","A publishing site presented as a think tank",[16,38,39,40,45],{},"The Hanover Institute for Public Policy is a site that publishes reports about Israel and Palestine. ",[20,41,44],{"href":42,"rel":43,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.404media.co\u002Fisrael-is-running-a-synthetic-think-tank-to-influence-ai-search-results\u002F",[24,25],"404 Media's investigation"," described it as a “synthetic think tank”: a publishing operation structured like a research institution, with question-led titles and citations but no individual author bylines. The outlet's interpretation is that the material was prepared to influence search engines and chatbot responses. That is a journalistic characterization, not a court finding or an independent measurement of impact.",[16,47,48,49,54],{},"Public records document a commercial relationship involving a state agency. A ",[20,50,53],{"href":51,"rel":52,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fefile.fara.gov\u002Fdocs\u002F7732-Exhibit-AB-20260602-0.pdf",[24,25],"Foreign Agents Registration Act filing dated 2 June 2026",", submitted to the US Department of Justice by Piro, states that the company was working for Israel Government Advertising Agency LaPam through Havas Media Germany. It describes the service as strategic communications and media relations. The filing also refers to communications activity intended to influence the US public. It does not make an explicit commitment to change AI answers.",[16,56,57,58,62,63,68],{},"FARA stands for the ",[59,60,61],"em",{},"Foreign Agents Registration Act",". ",[20,64,67],{"href":65,"rel":66,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.justice.gov\u002Fnsd-fara\u002Ffrequently-asked-questions",[24,25],"The Department of Justice explains"," that it is intended to disclose certain foreign-principal activities and who conducts them. A filing should not be read as a Department of Justice endorsement of the published material's accuracy.",[16,70,71,72,77],{},"The site's own current description matters too. ",[20,73,76],{"href":74,"rel":75,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fhanoverinstitute.com\u002Fabout",[24,25],"Hanover's About page"," identifies government funding and says it does not present itself as independent, non-partisan, or neutral. It explains the absence of individual bylines as an institutional publishing choice and a way to protect researchers. This is the institution's account of itself; it does not independently establish the method or accuracy of its reports. It does, however, make it harder to argue that the relationship was entirely hidden, given the current page.",[33,79,81],{"id":80},"where-ai-enters-the-picture","Where AI enters the picture",[16,83,84,85,90],{},"The connection is clearer in Piro's marketed service. On its ",[20,86,89],{"href":87,"rel":88,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fwww.wearepiro.com\u002Fai-story-optimization",[24,25],"AI Story Optimization page",", the company offers to examine the sources models use when describing a brand and to publish content in places those models draw on. The existence of that offer is directly observable. Whether it produces the outcome it promises requires separate measurement.",[16,92,93,98],{},[20,94,97],{"href":95,"rel":96,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fresponsiblestatecraft.org\u002Fisrael-influence-chatgpt\u002F",[24,25],"Responsible Statecraft reported"," that NewsGuard analyst Alice Lee assessed Hanover's reports as being prepared in ways suited to search engines and chatbots. The same report relays an earlier statement by Piro co-founder Daniel Rosenberg to Politico: he described the company's purpose as publishing sourced information and correcting misinformation. That statement shows how the company describes its purpose; it does not settle the reporting's assessment or the scale of any effect.",[16,100,101,102,107],{},"The technical distinction is straightforward. An AI assistant can search the web while answering a question and use a newly published page. ",[20,103,106],{"href":104,"rel":105,"target":26},"https:\u002F\u002Fhelp.openai.com\u002Fen\u002Farticles\u002F9237897-chatgpt-search",[24,25],"ChatGPT's search documentation"," explains that those responses can show links to their sources. A page can therefore enter a response without a model being retrained.",[16,109,110],{},"The possibility that content may later enter training data is separate. The documents examined for this article do not show that Hanover text was used to train any particular model. Nor can the appearance of a link in an AI answer show that the model has been changed permanently.",[16,112,113],{},[114,115],"img",{"alt":116,"src":117},"Dated public documents and publisher information are checked by a human hand before becoming a traceable AI answer, while an unsupported claim stays separate","\u002Fimages\u002Finline-ai-visibility-states\u002Fsource-trail-before-ai-answer.webp",[33,119,121],{"id":120},"an-issue-for-state-communication-too","An issue for state communication too",[16,123,124],{},"My conclusion from this case is that AI visibility also belongs on the agenda of state communication and public-diplomacy institutions. Public diplomacy includes how a country communicates with people in other countries. When people turn to AI assistants for information about a country, the sources those assistants use become part of that communication environment.",[16,126,127],{},"One case does not show that all states are doing the same thing. It does suggest that it is too narrow to treat the issue only as a brand's customer-acquisition concern.",[16,129,130],{},"The practical response does not have to be an order for hundreds of new articles. Someone considering an investment in Türkiye may receive an answer about incentives based on an expired document. A tourist may find outdated guidance instead of the current requirements. These are not measured outcomes in this case; they illustrate the questions and information sources worth monitoring.",[16,132,133],{},"For public institutions, the starting point is to keep their information current, accessible, and understandable in relevant languages. Then they can examine how they are represented in important questions. The same effort includes clear publisher and funding information, visible dates, and traceable corrections. An institution's position and an independent source's findings should be presented in a way readers can distinguish.",[16,135,136],{},[114,137],{"alt":138,"src":139},"A public communication team maintains current information in several language sections and checks representative questions against the source board","\u002Fimages\u002Finline-ai-visibility-states\u002Fpublic-information-needs-measurement.webp",[33,141,143],{"id":142},"the-measure-does-not-change-for-companies","The measure does not change for companies",[16,145,146,147,151],{},"For a company as much as for a public institution, appearing in an AI answer is not an outcome on its own. The answer needs to be accurate, include the necessary conditions, and help a person make a decision. The people-first principle in ",[20,148,150],{"href":149},"\u002Fdont-write-to-be-recommended-by-ai","Don't Write for AI Recommendations"," applies to this setting as well.",[16,153,154,155,159,160,164],{},"The measurement limit is the same. A few links found in selected queries cannot tell us what an entire audience has learned. The distinction between a limited sample and what users actually experience in ",[20,156,158],{"href":157},"\u002Fdo-ai-visibility-tools-really-work","Do AI Visibility Tools Really Work?"," does not disappear in state communication. ",[20,161,163],{"href":162},"\u002Fai-visibility-illusion-bing-citation-share","My comparison using Bing data"," also showed why a citation measure needs to be read within its own scope.",[16,166,167],{},"Before allocating a budget to AI visibility, an institution needs to decide which information problem it is trying to solve. Is it correcting inaccurate information, making current documents easier to find, or reducing applications based on the wrong conditions? If it cannot show which of those has changed, it may have produced more content and more citations without yet communicating better.",{"title":169,"searchDepth":170,"depth":170,"links":171},"",2,[172,173,174,175],{"id":35,"depth":170,"text":36},{"id":80,"depth":170,"text":81},{"id":120,"depth":170,"text":121},{"id":142,"depth":170,"text":143},[177,178],"ai","business",null,"2026-09-23","Reporting on the Hanover Institute raises a business question: which accurate, attributable sources do AI assistants surface when people ask for public information?",{"aiUse":183,"aiNote":184},"ai-assisted","The framing and central conclusion of this article were set by Evren Bal. AI-assisted tools supported source research and drafting.",false,"md","\u002Fimages\u002Fhero\u002Fai-visibility-states.avif","A hand checks an AI answer against dated institutional documents and their source trail.","Essay","en",{},true,5,{"title":11,"description":181},"AI Visibility and States: The Hanover Institute Case","ai-visibility-is-also-a-state-concern",[198,199,200,201],"ai-visibility","geo","public-diplomacy","content-strategy","ai-visibility-states","post","s1hEd7p2KmDQC-tpccYrZ0VAUjzR4k7YCSfa0TP94dI",{"en":206,"tr":207,"de":209},{"path":4,"title":11},{"path":6,"title":208},"AI görünürlüğü devletlerin de gündeminde",{"path":7,"title":210},"KI-Sichtbarkeit ist auch ein staatliches Thema",{"prev":212,"next":215,"others":218,"lucky":336,"readingTime":193},{"path":213,"title":214},"\u002Fai-assisted-migrations-deferred-work","AI Can Make Deferred Work Worth Doing",{"path":216,"title":217},"\u002Fai-knowledge-management-from-documents-to-better-decisions","Why Searching Company Knowledge with AI Is Not Enough",[219,222,225,228,231,233,236,237,240,243,246,249,252,255,258,261,264,267,270,273,276,279,282,285,288,291,294,297,300,303,306,309,312,315,318,321,324,327,330,333],{"path":220,"title":221},"\u002Fhow-ai-changes-the-experience-gap","Can a Junior Who Uses AI Well Outperform a Senior Expert?",{"path":223,"title":224},"\u002Fai-will-spread-across-turkiyes-businesses","AI in Türkiye: What Adoption Figures Leave Out",{"path":226,"title":227},"\u002Fthe-same-ai-does-not-create-the-same-competitive-advantage","The Same AI Does Not Create the Same Competitive Advantage",{"path":229,"title":230},"\u002Ftesting-a-button-treating-an-entire-website-redesign-as-a-sure-thing","Testing a Button, Treating an Entire Website Redesign as a Sure Thing",{"path":149,"title":232},"Getting Your Brand Recommended by AI Is the Wrong Goal. What Is the Right One?",{"path":234,"title":235},"\u002F1m-impressions-per-month-0-revenue-a-programmatic-seo-post-mortem","1M Impressions per Month, $0 Revenue: A Programmatic SEO Post-Mortem",{"path":216,"title":217},{"path":238,"title":239},"\u002Fhow-i-built-a-modern-infrastructure-using-open-source-tools-and-the-power-of-cloudflare","Why I Run camiler.org on a Single VPS",{"path":241,"title":242},"\u002Fone-victory-several-defeats","One Victory, Several Defeats",{"path":244,"title":245},"\u002Fwhy-sales-and-other-departments-keep-clashing","Why Sales and Other Departments Keep Clashing",{"path":247,"title":248},"\u002Fwhat-ai-can-automate-in-cro-research","What Can AI Actually Automate in CRO Research?",{"path":250,"title":251},"\u002Fis-your-ai-system-delivering-business-results","Is Your AI System Actually Delivering Business Results?",{"path":253,"title":254},"\u002Fhow-much-authority-should-ai-have","How Much Authority Should You Give an AI System?",{"path":256,"title":257},"\u002Fcio-cto-it-director-difference","CIO, CTO, and IT Director: What the Title Misses",{"path":259,"title":260},"\u002Fbringing-english-back-into-my-working-day","Bringing English Back Into My Working Day",{"path":262,"title":263},"\u002Fthe-ai-productivity-baseline-is-moving-faster-than-we-remember","AI Wasn’t Always This Good. We Just Got Used to It.",{"path":265,"title":266},"\u002Fthe-threshold-collapsed-to-zero","The Threshold Collapsed: What ProductLog Taught Me About Building in Public",{"path":268,"title":269},"\u002Fwhat-does-the-eu-ai-act-actually-regulate","What Is the EU AI Act, and What Does It Regulate?",{"path":271,"title":272},"\u002Fis-your-data-ready-for-ai","Is Your Data Ready for AI? Start With the Decision It Must Support",{"path":274,"title":275},"\u002Fbeyond-the-bot-lessons-from-building-a-chat-system-for-global-patients","What We Learned Building a Healthcare Chatbot for International Patients",{"path":277,"title":278},"\u002Fturkeys-first-real-time-mystery-shopping-reporting","Turkey's First Real-Time Mystery Shopping Reporting Platform",{"path":280,"title":281},"\u002Fhealthcare-ai-chatbot-triage-medical-device","AI in Healthcare: The Difference Between Chatbots, Triage, and Medical Devices",{"path":283,"title":284},"\u002Fai-value-is-not-always-more-work","AI's Value Is Not Always More Work",{"path":286,"title":287},"\u002Faccessing-know-how-is-not-the-same-as-creating-it","Accessing Know-How Is Not the Same as Creating It",{"path":289,"title":290},"\u002Fgoogle-generative-ai-data-ai-citation-timing","AI Visibility Dropped Before Search: The Google Data That Changed My Theory",{"path":292,"title":293},"\u002Fkeeping-customers-happy-isnt-enough","Keeping Customers Happy Isn’t Enough. You Have to Follow Up.",{"path":295,"title":296},"\u002Fwhat-makes-an-ai-system-specific-to-your-business","What Makes an AI System Specific to Your Business?",{"path":298,"title":299},"\u002Fwordpress-to-nuxt-ai-powered-content-pipeline","From WordPress to Nuxt: Building an AI-Powered Content Pipeline",{"path":301,"title":302},"\u002Fwhy-the-same-ai-model-produces-different-results","Why the Same AI Model Produces Different Results Across Applications",{"path":304,"title":305},"\u002Fllms-txt-was-never-the-point","llms.txt Was Never the Point",{"path":307,"title":308},"\u002Fai-transformation-redesign-work-not-cut-roles","AI Transformation Starts with Redesigning Work",{"path":310,"title":311},"\u002Feu-ai-act-after-risk-classification","EU AI Act: What Should You Do Once You Know the Risk Level?",{"path":313,"title":314},"\u002Fmanaging-technology-and-transforming-the-business-are-not-the-same","Managing Technology and Transforming the Business Are Not the Same Thing",{"path":316,"title":317},"\u002Fai-turned-a-refactor-i-wouldnt-do-into-a-one-hour-job","With AI, a Refactor I Wouldn't Bother With Took One Hour",{"path":319,"title":320},"\u002Fwhy-we-trust-ai-judgments","Why We Trust AI Judgments and What That Fails to Prove",{"path":322,"title":323},"\u002Fchatbot-data-third-party-ai-provider","What Happens When Chatbot Data Is Sent to a Third-Party AI Provider?",{"path":325,"title":326},"\u002Fcomprehension-debt-the-bill-comes-due-alone","Comprehension Debt: The Bill Comes Due Alone",{"path":328,"title":329},"\u002Fhow-llms-identify-experts","What Makes an LLM Recommend Someone as an Expert?",{"path":331,"title":332},"\u002Ffrom-rules-to-decisions-the-real-time-sales-intelligence-platform-we-built-at-vanity","Medical Tourism Lead Management: How We Moved from Manual Routing to a Real-Time Sales System",{"path":334,"title":335},"\u002Fwriting-with-ai-means-thinking-with-your-archive","Writing with AI Means Thinking About Your Archive, Too",{"path":337,"title":338},"\u002Fhow-much-does-the-eu-ai-act-affect-companies-outside-the-eu","How Much Does the EU AI Act Affect Companies Outside the EU?",[340,342,344,347],{"path":149,"title":232,"date":341},"2026-09-10",{"path":328,"title":329,"date":343},"2026-09-04",{"path":157,"title":345,"date":346},"Do AI Visibility Tools Really Work? What They Actually Measure","2026-08-23",{"path":304,"title":305,"date":346},[349,353,357],{"path":350,"title":351,"date":352},"\u002Ffrom-asking-questions-to-delegating-work","From Asking Questions to Delegating Work: What the Codex Study Shows","2026-09-01",{"path":354,"title":355,"date":356},"\u002Fdo-you-know-how-dependent-your-company-is-on-ai","Do You Know How Dependent Your Company Is on AI?","2026-08-22",{"path":358,"title":359,"date":360},"\u002Fif-ai-handles-the-execution-who-sets-the-strategy","If AI Handles the Execution, Who Sets the Strategy?","2026-09-09",1790204759621]